The Good: I love the weird west. Horror and westerns go together like homemade biscuits and gravy in my book. I really enjoy that Drake's vampiric nature is drawn from folklore, not Hollywood tradition. This movie definitely came from a simpler time, but I enjoyed it.
The Bad: Take the vampire element away and this is a standard B western. Also, because of the era and such, its just not scary. If you're wanting to see some blood-drenched vampire cowboy action, this is not your movie.
The Ugly: While this isn't an issue for me, if you don't like watching black and white films, you won't enjoy this one.
In Your Game:
AC 6  HD: 5 Attacks: Slam (1d6 damage) or Pistol (1d6 damage, range 60') Move: 12